A fence, retaining wall, driveway, building extension, or other improvement that has occupied neighboring property for many years does not automatically become lawful merely because the affected property owner has not previously demanded its removal.
However, California law recognizes certain circumstances in which longstanding possession or use of another person's property may establish legally enforceable rights.
One potential claim is adverse possession, which may allow a person to acquire ownership of land belonging to another property owner when all statutory requirements are satisfied.
Under California law, adverse possession generally requires actual, open, notorious, exclusive, hostile, and continuous possession under a claim of right or color of title for at least five years.
The claimant must also establish timely payment of all property taxes assessed against the disputed land during the required five-year period, as provided by Code of Civil Procedure § 325.
These requirements are demanding. Maintaining a fence or occupying a strip of neighboring land for decades does not, by itself, establish ownership.
A neighboring owner may also assert a prescriptive easement based on longstanding use of another person's property.
A prescriptive easement generally permits a particular use of land without transferring ownership. Establishing such a right requires proof of qualifying open, notorious, adverse, and continuous use for the statutory period.
However, California courts distinguish between a limited right to use another person's property and a claim that effectively excludes the owner from possession.
A claimant generally cannot avoid the property-tax requirements of adverse possession simply by characterizing exclusive occupation of neighboring land as a prescriptive easement.
Another potential issue is whether the neighboring owners or their predecessors established an agreed boundary when the original boundary was uncertain.
California's agreed-boundary doctrine applies only when its legal requirements are established. Longstanding acceptance of a fence does not automatically demonstrate that the owners entered into a binding boundary agreement.
In limited circumstances, a court may also consider granting an equitable easement when an encroachment resulted from an innocent mistake and the relative hardships strongly favor allowing the improvement to remain.
An equitable easement is not automatically established through the passage of time. Courts examine the encroaching party's conduct, the injury to the affected owner, and the comparative hardships involved.
The existence of a longstanding structure therefore requires careful evaluation of recorded title, surveys, historical possession, property-tax records, prior agreements, and the circumstances surrounding construction.
An attorney can determine whether the neighbor possesses a legally enforceable ownership or use right, whether removal remains available, and whether negotiation or litigation is appropriate to resolve the encroachment.
Hypothetical example
Two neighboring homeowners have lived on adjoining properties for more than twenty-five years.
A wooden fence separates their backyards, and one homeowner has maintained a garden and storage shed on the fenced side of the property.
When the other homeowner commissions a survey before selling the house, the survey reveals that the fence, garden, and shed occupy approximately eight feet of the homeowner's recorded property.
The neighboring owner refuses to move the improvements, arguing that the disputed area has been used exclusively for more than twenty-five years.
Counsel examines the recorded deeds, historical surveys, photographs, construction records, and circumstances surrounding installation of the fence.
The attorney also investigates whether the neighboring owner or previous owners paid the property taxes required to establish adverse possession.
Because the neighbor claims exclusive possession of the disputed strip, counsel evaluates whether the evidence supports adverse possession rather than merely a prescriptive easement.
The attorney also considers whether an enforceable agreed boundary or equitable easement might be asserted.
If the parties cannot reach an agreement, litigation may be necessary to determine ownership, evaluate competing property rights, and establish whether the improvements must be removed or may lawfully remain.